Poco sostenuto – Vivace from Symphony No 7
Ludwig van Beethoven
✒️ 1811–12 | ⏰ 12 minutes
Ludwig Van Beethoven
Born: Bonn, Germany, 1770
Died: Vienna, Austria, 1827
‘Music is like a dream. One that I cannot hear.’
Ludwig van Beethoven radically expanded the expressive bounds of music – especially in his symphonies, piano sonatas and string quartets – and if that meant adapting and developing conventional forms, so be it. He inherited the Classical-period style of Haydn and Mozart but moved into Romantic territory, engaging in his music with literary, political and philosophical ideas and ideals.
In his early 20s, he left his native Bonn for Vienna, where he became established as a composer, piano virtuoso and improviser of great ability. Largely following the Classical models of Haydn and Mozart in his ‘early’ period, he recognised signs of his impending deafness as early as 1796. In 1802, he revealed his suffering, alienation and his creative determination in a moving letter of despair, the Heiligenstadt Testament.
His ‘middle’ period was characterised by a broadening of form and an extension of harmony to suit his proto-Romantic expression, spawning the Symphonies Nos 2 to 8, notable piano sonatas, several string quartets and his only opera, Fidelio. He produced less music in his ‘late’ period (from 1813) but his last years saw his mould-breaking ‘Choral’ Symphony – featuring the famous setting of the poet Friedrich Schiller’s Ode to Joy – as well as an exploration of increasing profundity in the more intimate mediums of the piano sonata and string quartet.
The Music
Ludwig van Beethoven’s exuberant Seventh Symphony seems to reflect the rejuvenation he felt during a period of recuperation in the Bohemian spa town of Teplitz at the time he began writing the symphony in 1811.
Rhythmic drive was not new for Beethoven – you only need to think of the famous four-note opening of the Fifth Symphony (da-da-da DAH!) – but in the Seventh he took rhythm’s propulsive force to a new level. Each of the four movements is driven by constant repetition of tight rhythmic patterns.
The first movement opens with a slow introduction that is timeless and elemental, similar in mood to ‘The Representation of Chaos’ that opens Joseph Haydn’s oratorio The Creation. Already here there’s a hint of the prominent role rhythm will play in the symphony – the steady, regular pattern of the rising scales and the repetitions on a single note. Then there’s a heart-stopping Morse code-like exchange, with violins answering flute and oboe, before the movement proper, which is marked Vivace (lively). The whole of the movement is then dominated by a three-note bouncing figure, like an obsessive mantra.
My Melodies (Music for Eight Horns and Orchestra)
Helmut Lachenmann
✒️ 2016–18, rev 2019–2023 | ⏰ 37 minutes
Helmut Lachenmann
Born: Stuttgart, Germany, 1935
‘I always say, a composer who knows precisely what he wants only wants what he knows. And he must find a way beyond this.’
Born in Stuttgart, Helmut Lachenmann is the leading – and, at 89, the most senior – living figure associated with the group that grew up around the International Summer New Music Courses in Darmstadt. Begun in 1946, the courses drew composers such as Karlheinz Stockhausen, Luigi Nono, Bruno Maderna and Pierre Boulez to the city, forming a new centre for the European musical avant-garde, and developing a style based on super-organisation.
Not only was pitch (the notes of the scale) arranged in a predetermined pattern – a technique (known as ‘serialism’) that had been developed by Arnold Schoenberg over 25 years earlier – but this pre-ordering was now extended to other musical elements: note-durations, dynamics (loudness), tempo (speed), even articulation (attack). This was a radical reaction to what were seen as the extravagances of the Romantics and post-Romantics, a chance to reinvent music, to blow apart traditional ideas of melody, harmony and rhythm. Abstract and process-driven, this was the pursuit of music formed in the image of … nothing at all.
So Lachenmann’s sound-world is unsurprisingly challenging and provocative, but he was not willing to apply a purely mathematical template. He soon came to believe that the avant-garde, in completely rejecting beauty and expression, had ‘failed society and reality’. He forged a path in which expressivity dictated the structure of a piece, rather than the other way around, leading to his idea of ‘musique concrète instrumentale’. Unlike the electronic experiments of ‘musique concrète’, based on recorded environmental sounds, in ‘musique concrète instrumentale’, human agency is key – you hear, in his words, ‘what materials and energies are involved and what resistance is encountered’. Lachenmann opened up a whole new continuum between pitch on the one hand and noise on the other, and he did so through exploring so-called ‘extended techniques’ – new, non-conventional ways of interacting with instruments to create unorthodox sounds.
The Music
If you think the title ‘My Melodies’ implies that Lachenmann, who wrote the piece in his early eighties, has softened in his autumn years, think again. These are very much ‘his’ melodies – you could say a subversion of melody: fragmented, alternative, at best, deeply concealed. The fact that he quotes a German folk song near the end or (even less audibly) a brief theme from the Second Piano Concerto by Serge Rachmaninoff – ironically, the king of spinning a good tune – is neither here nor there. This piece is a symphony of precisely notated air-blowing, swishing, scraping and breathing (‘It really puffs and pants,’ he says), with crisp punctuations and bell-like resonances joining in an ever-shifting and unpredictable canvas.
The eight solo horns perform not as individuals but as one super-horn. Running as a continuous span of around 40 minutes, there’s little to get a handle on in terms of form or structure. Which means that there are no preconceptions as to how we should listen or respond. The only requirement is to stick with it to the end. Lachenmann himself never judges a piece after only one listening since, he says, at this stage, ‘I’m out in the jungle’. Tonight we’re all out in the jungle and the best thing we can do is to enter with heightened senses and a spirit of adventure.
Keep Listening
Delve deeper into the music featured in our Half Six Fix series, and find related music recommendations, with our Half Six Fix playlist.
Ilan Volkov
Conductor
Ilan Volkov is a conductor who remains continually curious, open to innovation and collaboration, and tackles the newest and most alternative scores while also conducting the standard repertoire, including opera. He was Assistant Conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra at the age of only 19, and at 23 became the youngest titled conductor of a BBC orchestra when he became Chief Conductor of the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra; he is now the BBC SSO’s Creative Partner, curating boundary-crossing projects. From 2011 to 2014 he was Chief Conductor of the Iceland Symphony Orchestra and in 2022 became Principal Guest Conductor of the Brussels Philharmonic. In 2012 he founded the Tectonics festival, focusing on new and experimental music, which has had iterations in Athens, Glasgow, New York, Oslo and Reykjavik.
LSO Horns
Diego Incertis Sánchez LSO Principal Horn
Diego Incertis Sánchez was born in Valladolid, Spain, where he started playing the horn at age eight under the guidance of Carlos Balaguer. He went on to learn with Radovan Vlatkovic and Rodolfo Epelde in Madrid, before transferring to the Royal College of Music in London to study with Nigel Black, Timothy Jones and Jeffrey Bryant. He has previously held both the Third Horn and Principal chairs at the Philharmonia Orchestra, with whom he appeared as a soloist playing Robert Schumann’s Konzertstück for Four Horns and Orchestra. He often appears as a guest Principal with other London orchestras and is a Professor of Horn at the Royal College of Music.
Timothy Jones LSO Principal Horn
Timothy Jones started playing the horn at the age of 15 and won a position playing in the Munich Philharmonic at the age of 17. He has previously held positions with the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra and the Academy of St Martin in the Fields. As a soloist he has appeared at the Salzburg Festival, Pacific Music Festival, Royal Festival Hall and the Schausspielhaus and Philharmonie halls in Berlin. His recording of the Kenneth Fuchs Horn Concerto with the LSO was nominated for a Grammy award, and his recording of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart’s Second Horn Concerto with the LSO is one of the most streamed tracks on the LSO Live label. He is a Professor of Horn at the Royal College of Music and Director and Co-Owner of the renowned horn company PAXMAN Limited.
Angela Barnes LSO Second Horn
Having started horn lessons with her mother aged eight, Angela Barnes went on to study with Lizzie Davis at Chetham’s School of Music and later Hugh Seenan, Jeffrey Bryant, Richard Bissill and Jonathan Lipton at the Guildhall School, where she is now a Professor of Horn. During her final year of study she was offered the Second Horn position with the LSO, and upon joining became the first female member of the Orchestra’s brass section. Solo appearances include Richard Strauss’ Second Horn Concerto with the BBC Symphony Orchestra, as part of the BBC Young Musician Concerto Final and Robert Schumann’s Konzertstück with the LSO in Berlin’s Philharmonie.
Jonathan Maloney LSO Fourth Horn
Jonathan Maloney was born and raised in Glasgow, and started learning the horn in school. He studied at the Royal Northern College of Music with Lizzie Davis and Julian Plummer, and then the Royal College of Music in London with Simon Rayner and Jeffrey Bryant. After graduating, he worked throughout the UK and abroad as a freelance musician and was acting Fourth Horn with the Philharmonia Orchestra from 2016–2018 before joining the LSO as Fourth Horn in 2022. As a soloist Jonathan has appeared in the solo quartet for Robert Schumann’s Konzertstück with the Philharmonia Orchestra at London’s Royal Festival Hall, and has recently been appointed Professor of Horn at the Royal College of Music.
Katy Woolley
Born in Exeter, Katy Woolley began playing horn at age ten. She went on to study with Sue Dent and later Simon Rayner, graduating from the Royal College of Music in London with a first class degree and receiving the Tagore Gold Medal from the Prince of Wales. Having been appointed to the Third Horn position whilst still a student, Katy was appointed Principal Horn of the Philharmonia Orchestra at age 22. In 2019 she was appointed Principal Horn of the Concertgebouworkest in Amsterdam, and returns to London as International Visiting Professor of Horn at the Royal Academy of Music. As a soloist she has appeared with the Philharmonia Orchestra, London Mozart Players and New York Philharmonic.
Annemarie Federle
Annemarie Federle was appointed as Principal Horn of the Aurora Orchestra in October 2022, and Principal Horn of the LPO in January 2023. At the age of 17, she won the Brass Category Final of the 2020 BBC Young Musician competition. She was a semifinalist in the 2021 ARD International Music Competition in Munich, and winner of the Gianni Bergamo Classic Music Award in the same year. Annemarie recently graduated with First Class Honours from the Royal Academy of Music in London, where she studied with Richard Watkins, David Pyatt, Michael Thompson, Kira Doherty and Roger Montgomery.
Richard Watkins
Richard Watkins was Principal Horn of the Philharmonia Orchestra from 1985 until 1996, and is currently a member of the Nash Ensemble and a founder member of London Winds and the Transatlantic Horn Quartet. He has appeared at many of the world’s most prestigious venues in the UK, Europe and the US, as well as being one of the most in-demand studio musicians, regularly recording for film and tv. One of his more recent appearances was as the Solo Horn on the score for Netflix’s multi-award winning TV series, The Crown. Watkins holds the Dennis Brain Chair of Horn Playing at the Royal Academy of Music where he is also a Fellow.
Ben Goldscheider
Ben Goldscheider has premiered over 50 new works for the horn to date including concerti, solo, chamber and cross-genre projects including with live electronics and lighting. Born in London in 1997, Ben studied at the Royal College of Music Junior Department with Susan Dent and in 2020 Ben completed his studies with honours at the Barenboim-Said Academy in Berlin with Radek Baborák. He was a prize-winner at the 2019 YCAT International Auditions, Concerto Finalist in the 2016 BBC Young Musician Competition, and an ECHO Rising Star for the 2021/22 season nominated by the Barbican, London, and now holds professorships at the Royal Conservatory in Antwerp and is the Artist in Association at the Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama.
The London Symphony Orchestra
At the London Symphony Orchestra, we strive to inspire hearts and minds through world-leading music-making. We were established in 1904 as one of the first orchestras shaped by its musicians, and today we’re ranked among the world’s top orchestras. As Resident Orchestra at the Barbican since the Centre opened in 1982, we perform some 70 concerts here every year. We also perform over 50 concerts a year to audiences throughout the UK and worldwide, and deliver a far-reaching programme of recordings, live-streams and on-demand broadcasts.
Through our world-leading learning and community programme, LSO Discovery, we’re connecting people from all walks of life to the power of great music. Our musicians are at the heart of this unique programme. In 1999, we formed our own recording label, LSO Live, which has become one of the world’s most talked-about classical labels. As a leading orchestra for film, we’ve entertained millions with classic scores for Star Wars, Indiana Jones and many more.
On Stage
Leader
Andrej Power
First Violins
Frederik Paulsson
Clare Duckworth
Ginette Decuyper
Laura Dixon
Maxine Kwok
William Melvin
Stefano Mengoli
Claire Parfitt
Elizabeth Pigram
Laurent Quénelle
Sylvain Vasseur
Olatz Ruiz de Gordejuela
Second Violins
David Alberman
Thomas Norris
Sarah Quinn
Miya Väisänen
David Ballesteros
Matthew Gardner
Naoko Keatley
Belinda McFarlane
Csilla Pogány
Paul Robson
Helena Buckie
Violas
Gillianne Haddow
Malcolm Johnston
Anna Bastow
Thomas Beer
Julia O’Riordan
Robert Turner
Mizuho Ueyama
Anna Dorothea Vogel
Cellos
Rebecca Gilliver
Alastair Blayden
Salvador Bolón
Ève-Marie Caravassilis
Daniel Gardner
Ghislaine McMullin
Victoria Simonsen
Jessie Ann Richardson
Double Basses
David Desimpelaere
Patrick Laurence
Thomas Goodman
Joe Melvin
Jani Pensola
Simon Oliver
Adam Wynter
Evangeline Tang
Flutes
Gareth Davies
Imogen Royce
Piccolos
Sharon Williams
Patricia Moynihan
Oboes
Thomas Hutchinson
Rosie Jenkins
Ruth Contractor
Mana Shibata
Clarinets
Chris Richards
Sarah Thurlow
Andrew Harper
Bass Clarinet
Ferran Garcerà Perelló
Bassoons
Rachel Gough
Joost Bosdijk
Dominic Tyler
Martin Field
Horns
Timothy Jones
Angela Barnes
Anna Douglass
Joel Ashford
Trumpets
James Fountain
Adam Wright
Richard Blake
David Geoghegan
Trombones
Richard Watkin
Jonathan Hollick
Robyn Anderson
Bass Trombone
Paul Milner
Tubas
Peter Smith
Richard Evans
Timpani
Nigel Thomas
Patrick King
Percussion
Sam Walton
David Jackson
Tom Edwards
Helen Edordu
Jeremy Cornes
Aidy Spillett
Harps
Bryn Lewis
Helen Tunstall
Pianos
Elizabeth Burley
Ian Tindale
Electric Guitars
Mats Scheidegger
Tom Ellis
Programme Notes Edward Bhesania. Edward Bhesania is a music journalist and editor who writes for The Stage, The Strad and the Guildhall School of Music & Drama.
LSO Visual Identity & Concept Design Bridge & Partners
We hope you enjoyed the concert. We’d love to get your thoughts on it through our short survey.